Suggested Evaluation Criteria
The specific requirements for Wiki solutions vary, the following sets of questions represent a composite for evaluating an enterprise Wiki implementation:
 
Usability:
  • Is the User Interface easy for the client to administer and use?
  • How easy is it for the user administrator to add and subtract users and user group levels from the Wiki?
  • Can you manage all the different information that is entering the knowledge bank as well as easily determine what user group levels can view what?
  • Can a remote user enter my network through the Internet without additional configuration?
  • Was the “HELP” documentation provided online easy to follow and understand?
  • Does the editor provide for a non-technical user to build valuable pieces of content?
  • Is collaboration, based on a Web-page of information, easy to use?
  • Can the information be shared; print, email, RSS?
  • Is there notification built to alert users on updated information and collaboration?
  • Will I be able to rev-back to a previous version, if necessary?
  • Can I incorporate sound files?
  • Can I copy information from existing files; word, excel, etc.?
 
Manageability:
  • Can the user control the style to blend with their existing brand or intranet/extranet?
  • Can management view, real-time, the use of the enterprise Wiki and expert knowledge?
  • Can documents be uploaded and managed as part of a Web-page?
  • Can an expert message be promoted to the knowledge bank with ease?
 
Security:
  • How secure is the Wiki?
  • Does it provide a high level of authentication?
  • Does it provide various user-levels of authentication? 
  • Does it support higher levels of authentication including SSL?
  • Does it allow me to determine and provide user-level access to the content and Wiki capabilities?
  • Does it allow me to filter presentation of information?
  • Can a non-technical user administer security?
  • Can Wiki capabilities (editing, discussing, etc.) be controlled globally and down to a page level?
  • Can cookies be stored for ease of use?
  • Does it provide secured message (email) answering of expert questions
 
Performance:
  • How fast is the website to present information?
  • Will the performance level support my network bandwidth requirements?
  • Can I search, and advance search, without requiring the content editor to tag web pages?
  • Does notification of updated content and alerting promote ease of use and integration with enterprise workflow?
 
Support:
  • Do I have access to support information as well as a support person?
  • How much pre- and post-support will be required?
  • How long does implementation take? 
 
Cost:
  • What is the cost of the enterprise Wiki?
  • How much will the Wiki save me in reference to an email or phone call and reducing the time spent in answering the same question over and over?
  • How much will the Wiki benefit me in retaining and gathering corporate knowledge?
  • How much time will be reduce in supporting a working team or implementation project instead of using share drives, email and/or static web pages? 
  • Can the investment be easily expanded to non-employee partners?
  • Will utilizing a Wiki help generate revenue?